Continuing Court Battle Over Worker Classification AB5 in CA

The Ongoing Legal Saga

In a surprising twist, the California Trucking Association (CTA) and the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) have decided to challenge a recent court decision that upheld Assembly Bill 5 (AB5), a law significantly impacting worker classification of independent contractors in California. And so, we turn the page on yet another episode in the ongoing saga that kicked off with AB5 rolling out at the start of 2020.

Despite previous setbacks in court, including a denial for review by the U.S. Supreme Court in June 2022, these trucking associations are not backing down. Their commitment to appealing at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals highlights the impact of AB5 on truckers’ worker classification and the trucking industry.

Understanding AB5

AB5, known informally as the “gig worker bill,” introduces the ABC test to determine employment status. Now, where things get a bit heated is with the test’s “B prong.” This rule insists that for a worker to fly solo as an independent contractor, their job should fall outside what the business typically handles. Imagine a future where trucking outfits no longer lean on lone wolf drivers – that’s what we’re looking at here, a complete transformation of operations.

You can read more information about trucking industry regulations.

The Core of the Legal Issues

With eyes firmly set on overturning AB5; the CTA and the OIODA have made clear where problems lie. First, they argue that the law directly conflicts with the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act that prevents state regulations over prices, routes, and services of freight carriers. Second, they claim that AB5 violates the Commerce Clause of the Constitution by adding extra load to interstate commerce, which they regard as constitutionally unfair.

The organizations are also worried that AB5’s exceptions might not treat everyone fairly under the law. Many sectors enjoy special perks under these laws, except for those in the trucking industry. This has brought claims of bias against truckers.

Latest Truck Driver News Stories about the trucking industry regulations:

• Zero-Emissions Mandate Sparks Lawsuit Against California
• CDL Testing Rule Change Denied – Florida Proposal Falls Short
• Autonomous Vehicle Industry Seeks Clarity in US Regulation
• CMV Speed Limiter Law Now in Effect for British Columbia
• Seeking Clarity in Autonomous Vehicle Regulations

The Impact on Truck Drivers and Companies

If you’re driving a truck or managing those who do, get ready – things are about to shift in a major way. Should AB5 be fully enforced without exemptions for truckers, it could compel companies to reclassify many independent drivers as employees. This change in worker classification would not only affect the cost structures and operational flexibility of trucking companies but also the livelihoods of many drivers accustomed to the independence of contracting.

Truckers, particularly those rolling through California’s highways, might see a dip in job openings and more red tape. Some may even avoid California routes altogether to escape the law’s reach, potentially disrupting freight movement in and out of one of the country’s key economic hubs.

Looking Ahead

As the appeal process unfolds, the trucking industry will be watching closely. Choices made could soon heavily shift things around for trucking companies all over the US. For now, the trucking community remains hopeful yet prepared for all outcomes.

In challenging AB5 worker classification head-on, both CTA and OOIDA make us all take a second look—not merely at what it means for them but also its wider effects on American jobs in essential sectors like trucking. Step by step, as each court decision drops, watch how our job landscapes morph and evolve—especially in transport circles where trucks rule—and gear up because things will never quite look or operate the same way again.

For more information and articles from the trucking industry, follow us on Facebook or subscribe to our Truck Driver News newsletter.