New York Toll Surcharge is Facing Trucking Industry Pushback

Trucking Groups Push Back Against New York’s 1% Toll Surcharge

A coalition of trucking companies is urging state officials to reconsider a new toll surcharge. It will add 1% to commercial vehicle tolls on the New York State Thruway starting January 1. Industry groups say this charge creates new costs without a clear explanation of how the extra revenue will be used.

The surcharge has drawn sharp criticism from trucking operators who already face high business expenses, shifting freight demand, and tight margins. They describe the new charge as a “backdoor toll increase” and say the rollout lacked transparency.

Industry Letter Opposes the Toll Surcharge

In a joint letter, the coalition states that the toll surcharge adds a new financial burden for carriers operating across New York. The groups argue that normal public review steps were bypassed and that stakeholders were given little time to prepare before the increase takes effect.

They also note that the Thruway Authority has not explained how the additional revenue from the surcharge will be used. Without a clear funding plan or public discussion, the groups say carriers cannot understand why the fee is necessary or how it benefits the system.

Industry representatives emphasize that toll adjustments are usually handled through a formal process with hearings, public notice, and detailed financial justification. They believe this surcharge did not follow those steps.

Toll Surcharge Adds Pressure to Operating Costs

Trucking companies say even a 1% increase can have a wide impact on operations. Many carriers run long routes through New York and already face some of the highest toll costs in the region. Adding a toll surcharge on top of fuel, equipment, insurance, and regulatory expenses can create more pressure on budgets.

Some carriers may consider adjusting pricing or rerouting freight to avoid additional toll expenses. The letter notes that higher transportation costs can also influence consumer prices if companies pass those costs along the supply chain.

Industry says the timing of the increase creates additional challenges, especially as companies manage winter demand and fluctuating freight volumes.

Concerns About Transparency

A key point raised by the coalition is the lack of transparency around the toll surcharge. They argue that the increase was introduced outside the typical toll-setting process. This, therefore, limits the ability of carriers and the public to respond or provide feedback.

Commercial vehicles on the Thruway already pay high toll rates relative to many other states. Groups say that any new charge should come with detailed information about the reasons behind it and how the funds will support infrastructure needs.

Without that information, the surcharge appears to be a revenue action rather than a planned part of a long-term transportation strategy.

Industry Calls for State Review of the Toll Surcharge

The letter urges state leaders to review the toll surcharge before it takes effect. The signatory organizations request that officials delay or remove the charge until a full, transparent explanation is provided.

Trucking groups say they want to support the maintenance of New York’s transportation network. However, they need clarity on how toll revenue is managed. They also call for more open communication between the state, the Thruway Authority, and the trucking industry in future toll decisions.

Economic Impact of the Toll Surcharge on Freight

The letter points out that freight demand has been uneven over the past two years, making cost management more difficult for carriers. New expenses introduced without adequate notice can disrupt planning for both large and small operators.

Industry groups warn that toll increases may shift traffic patterns as companies look for lower-cost routes. This could lead to higher congestion on local roads or neighboring corridors, which could affect travel efficiency and safety.

They stress that keeping stable toll levels is an important part of supporting the state’s supply chain.

What Comes Next

The toll surcharge remains scheduled to take effect at the start of the new year. Unless officials take action, carriers expect to see the new fee added to their toll statements.

The issue has drawn renewed attention to how toll decisions are made and how transportation revenue is managed. Trucking groups say they support infrastructure investments but want a clearer process with more transparency.

For now, the industry continues to monitor the situation and hopes the state will reconsider the surcharge before it becomes permanent.

RELATED: New York City Tolls Spark Warning from the DOT Secretary, New Tire Cost Bill Seeks Improvements in the Industry, Over 140 Illegal Truck Drivers Now In Jail